Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Marco Island

IberiaBank Mortgage (now part of First Horizon Bank) maintains a strong presence in Southwest Florida with Michael Kistler's Marco Island office consistently receiving exceptional ratings. With over two decades of experience specializing in Florida's unique coastal property market, they offer personalized service for primary residences, vacation homes, and investment properties. Their expertise in jumbo loans and waterfront property financing makes them particularly well-suited for Marco Island's luxury real estate market. Customers consistently praise their responsiveness, local market knowledge, and ability to navigate complex coastal property transactions.

As a locally-owned and operated mortgage broker serving Marco Island exclusively since 1996, Marco Island Mortgage has built an outstanding reputation for deep community knowledge and personalized service. They leverage their extensive network of lenders to secure competitive rates while providing white-glove service throughout the loan process. Specializing in both primary residences and vacation properties, they understand the unique aspects of island living, including flood zone requirements and condo financing. Their long-standing presence and commitment to client education have earned them numerous local awards and consistent five-star reviews.

Supreme Lending's Naples office serves the entire Southwest Florida region including Marco Island, with a team that specializes in coastal property financing. With over two decades of experience, they offer a comprehensive range of loan products and are particularly noted for their efficient processing and competitive jumbo loan rates. Their local loan officers understand the specific challenges of Marco Island properties, including older construction, elevation requirements, and insurance considerations. The company receives consistent praise for their transparent communication, technological efficiency, and ability to close loans quickly even for complex waterfront transactions.