Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Buffalo

Horizon Bank is a well-established regional financial institution with deep roots in northern Indiana, serving the Buffalo area through their nearby Logansport branch. With over 150 years of banking experience, they offer personalized mortgage services with local decision-making. Their mortgage team receives consistently high ratings for responsive communication, competitive rates, and guiding borrowers through the entire home financing process. As a community-focused bank, they understand the local real estate market and provide various loan options including specialized construction loans for rural areas like Buffalo.

Ruoff Mortgage is one of Indiana's most highly-rated mortgage lenders with extensive experience serving rural communities throughout the state, including Buffalo. Founded in 1958, they've built an exceptional reputation for customer service, earning thousands of positive reviews for their efficient processing and competitive rates. Their local loan officers understand Indiana's rural property financing needs and offer specialized USDA loans perfect for the Buffalo area. Ruoff consistently ranks among the top mortgage lenders in the Midwest for customer satisfaction and closing efficiency.

Fairway Independent Mortgage has a strong Lafayette office that actively serves the Buffalo area with excellent customer satisfaction ratings. As a nationwide lender with local presence, they combine the resources of a large mortgage company with personalized service from local loan officers who understand the specific needs of White County homebuyers. They're particularly noted for their digital mortgage experience and fast closing times, while maintaining the personal touch crucial for first-time homebuyers. Their extensive loan product menu includes specialized options perfect for rural Indiana properties.