Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Cayuga

First Financial Bank has been serving Indiana communities for over 160 years with a strong presence in rural areas like Cayuga. Their mortgage team specializes in agricultural and rural property financing, offering personalized service with local decision-making. They maintain excellent customer satisfaction ratings for their competitive rates and deep understanding of local property values and market conditions in Vermillion County and surrounding areas.

Meridian Mortgage Corporation is a highly-rated Indiana-based mortgage broker that serves the entire state, including rural communities like Cayuga. With nearly 25 years of experience, they specialize in finding the best loan programs for clients in smaller communities. Their exceptional 4.9 rating reflects their commitment to customer service, and they're known for their expertise with USDA rural development loans which are particularly relevant for Cayuga area homebuyers.

Ruoff Mortgage is an Indiana-based lender with over 60 years of experience serving communities throughout the state. They maintain dedicated loan officers who specialize in rural Indiana properties and have extensive experience with Cayuga and Vermillion County real estate. Their high rating and substantial review count demonstrate consistent customer satisfaction. Ruoff is particularly noted for their competitive rates on conventional and government-backed loans, with specialized knowledge of agricultural and rural property financing needs.