Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Evanston

Evansville Teachers FCU is one of Southern Indiana's most trusted mortgage lenders with an exceptional 4.8-star rating. While headquartered in Evansville, they serve the entire Evansville metropolitan area including Evanston. With over 85 years of community banking experience, they offer highly competitive rates and personalized service through local loan officers who understand the Southern Indiana housing market. Their mortgage team specializes in first-time homebuyer programs and offers a comprehensive range of loan products with exceptional customer service ratings.

Old National Bank has deep roots in Southern Indiana with a strong presence throughout the Evansville region, including service to Evanston residents. As one of the largest regional banks in the area, they offer comprehensive mortgage solutions with local decision-making and personalized service. Their 4.6-star rating reflects consistent customer satisfaction, and they maintain multiple branch locations throughout the Tri-State area. With nearly two centuries of banking experience, they provide competitive rates and a wide array of mortgage products tailored to Indiana homebuyers.

Guild Mortgage's Evansville branch serves the Evanston area with exceptional 4.7-star ratings for their local mortgage services. As a nationwide lender with strong local presence, they combine the resources of a large mortgage company with personalized service from local loan officers who understand the Evansville housing market. They specialize in various government-backed loans and first-time homebuyer programs, with particular expertise in FHA and VA lending. Their local team has built a strong reputation for guiding borrowers through the entire mortgage process with transparency and efficiency.