Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in New Castle

First Financial Federal Credit Union stands as the premier local mortgage lender serving New Castle directly with deep community roots since 1935. As a member-owned financial institution, they consistently receive exceptional ratings for personalized service, competitive rates, and local underwriting expertise. Their mortgage team provides comprehensive guidance through every step of the home financing process, offering specialized programs for first-time homebuyers and flexible loan options. With physical branches throughout Henry County and surrounding areas, they maintain strong local presence and understanding of the New Castle housing market.

Ruoff Mortgage has established itself as one of Indiana's most respected mortgage lenders with extensive experience serving the New Castle area from their nearby Muncie location. With over 60 years in business and thousands of outstanding reviews, they've built a reputation for exceptional customer service, competitive rates, and streamlined digital mortgage processes. Their local loan officers have deep knowledge of Henry County real estate markets and provide personalized guidance through conventional, government-backed, and specialty loan programs. Ruoff consistently ranks among the top mortgage lenders in Indiana for customer satisfaction and closing efficiency.

Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation brings national lending power with strong local expertise to New Castle homebuyers through their Indianapolis-area branch network. As one of America's largest mortgage lenders with over 25 years of experience, they combine extensive loan product options with personalized local service. Their Indiana-based loan officers have particular expertise in rural and suburban markets like New Castle, offering specialized programs including USDA loans ideal for Henry County properties. Fairway maintains exceptional customer satisfaction ratings for their responsive communication, competitive rates, and efficient closing processes across all loan types.