Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in New Palestine

First Merchants Bank stands out as the primary local banking institution actually located in New Palestine, providing personalized mortgage services with deep community roots. As a well-established regional bank with over 130 years of history, they offer the advantage of local decision-making combined with comprehensive mortgage products. Their New Palestine branch provides face-to-face service and local underwriting expertise, making them particularly strong for first-time homebuyers and those seeking construction loans in the area. The bank maintains exceptional customer satisfaction ratings and offers competitive rates with the convenience of having your mortgage and banking services in one trusted local institution.

Ruoff Mortgage is one of Indiana's highest-rated mortgage lenders with a strong presence throughout central Indiana, including serving the New Palestine area. Founded in Fort Wayne and now headquartered in Carmel, they've built an outstanding reputation for exceptional customer service and competitive rates. With thousands of 5-star reviews across multiple platforms, they're particularly noted for their efficient closing processes and personalized attention. Their deep understanding of Indiana's housing market and extensive experience with local property types makes them an excellent choice for New Palestine residents seeking reliable mortgage services with Indiana-based expertise.

Stockton Mortgage has established itself as a premier mortgage lender serving the greater Indianapolis metropolitan area, including Hancock County and New Palestine. With over 20 years of experience specializing in Indiana mortgages, they offer exceptional local market knowledge and streamlined digital processes. They're particularly strong in construction lending and jumbo loans, making them ideal for custom home builds in New Palestine's growing communities. Their team includes local mortgage experts who understand the specific dynamics of Hancock County's real estate market, and they maintain consistently high customer satisfaction ratings with personalized service from application through closing.