Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Spiceland

CrossCountry Mortgage is a highly-rated national lender with a strong local presence in Eastern Indiana, serving Spiceland and surrounding communities. With exceptional 4.8-star ratings from hundreds of customers, they offer comprehensive mortgage solutions including specialized programs for first-time homebuyers. Their New Castle office provides personalized service with the backing of a national company, featuring competitive rates and a streamlined digital application process. They're particularly noted for their responsive communication and expertise in rural housing loans suitable for the Spiceland area.

First Financial Bank has deep roots in Eastern Indiana with over 160 years of service to communities including Spiceland. As a established regional bank with strong local presence, they offer personalized mortgage services with the stability of a long-standing financial institution. Their 4.6-star rating reflects consistent customer satisfaction, particularly for their construction loans and local market expertise. The bank is known for competitive rates, local underwriting decisions, and comprehensive financial services that make the homebuying process seamless for Henry County residents.

Ruoff Mortgage is an Indiana-based lender with an outstanding 4.9-star rating from over 400 reviews, serving Spiceland and surrounding areas with exceptional dedication. As a family-owned company with deep Indiana roots since 1958, they combine local market knowledge with extensive mortgage expertise. They're particularly strong in rural lending programs and offer incredibly responsive service with many customers noting quick closings and personalized attention. Their USDA loan expertise makes them an excellent choice for Spiceland area homebuyers, and they consistently rank among the highest-rated mortgage lenders in Central Indiana.