Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in West Tisbury

Martha's Vineyard Bank is the premier local financial institution serving West Tisbury and the entire Martha's Vineyard community. With deep roots in the island community since 1994, they specialize in understanding the unique real estate market of Martha's Vineyard, including vacation homes, primary residences, and construction lending. Their local underwriting team provides personalized service and competitive rates specifically tailored to island properties. Customers consistently praise their responsive service, local decision-making, and extensive knowledge of Vineyard real estate nuances.

Fairway Independent Mortgage's Martha's Vineyard branch has built an exceptional reputation for serving West Tisbury and surrounding communities with highly competitive rates and outstanding customer service. The local team specializes in both primary residences and vacation properties, with particular expertise in jumbo loans common in the Martha's Vineyard market. Their extensive product portfolio and efficient processing have earned them numerous industry awards and outstanding customer reviews citing their responsiveness, transparency, and ability to close complex loans efficiently.

Guaranteed Rate serves West Tisbury through their Cape Cod and Islands regional office, bringing national lending power with local expertise. As one of the largest retail mortgage lenders in the U.S., they offer highly competitive rates and a streamlined digital mortgage experience while maintaining strong local presence. Their experienced loan officers specialize in Martha's Vineyard properties, including the unique considerations for island homes. Customers consistently praise their efficient process, competitive pricing, and the local team's deep knowledge of Massachusetts real estate markets and regulations.