Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Columbia

American Federal Mortgage Corporation stands out as one of New Jersey's highest-rated mortgage lenders with exceptional customer satisfaction ratings. Located just 15 minutes from Columbia in Phillipsburg, this established lender has served Warren County communities for over two decades. They specialize in personalized mortgage solutions with competitive rates and have built a strong reputation for their local market expertise. Their high rating reflects consistent excellence in customer service, transparent communication, and efficient loan processing. As a direct lender, they offer in-house underwriting which often results in faster closings.

Cornerstone Mortgage Corporation has been serving Northwest New Jersey communities including Columbia for over 20 years. Located in nearby Augusta, they have extensive experience with Warren County properties and local market conditions. Their exceptional 4.8 rating stems from their commitment to personalized service and competitive loan products. Specializing in first-time homebuyer programs and government-backed loans, they've helped hundreds of local families achieve homeownership. Their team provides comprehensive guidance through the entire mortgage process, earning consistent praise for their responsiveness and expertise.

Fulton Bank brings over 140 years of banking experience with a strong regional presence throughout New Jersey, including dedicated mortgage services for Columbia and Warren County. While headquartered in Pennsylvania, they maintain multiple New Jersey branches and have specialized mortgage consultants serving the Northwest NJ region. Their high rating reflects their stability, competitive rates, and comprehensive mortgage options. As an established financial institution, they offer the security of a large bank with personalized local service. Customers consistently praise their professional mortgage team for making complex processes straightforward and stress-free.