Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Allegany

Evans Bank is a highly-rated Western New York institution with deep roots in the region, serving Allegany and surrounding communities for nearly a century. They offer personalized mortgage services with local decision-making, competitive rates, and expertise in rural property financing. Their mortgage team receives exceptional customer satisfaction ratings for their responsive service and knowledge of local market conditions, making them a top choice for Allegany homebuyers seeking a community-focused lender.

Five Star Bank has a strong physical presence in the Allegany area with their Wellsville branch located just minutes away. As a established regional bank serving Western New York for over a century, they offer comprehensive mortgage solutions with local underwriting and personalized service. Their expertise in rural and small-town property financing, combined with competitive rates and first-time homebuyer programs, makes them an excellent choice for Allegany residents seeking reliable mortgage services.

Tompkins Community Bank serves the Allegany area through their Western New York footprint and offers robust mortgage lending services with a reputation for excellent customer service. While headquartered in Ithaca, they have significant presence throughout the region and specialize in understanding the unique needs of Upstate New York homebuyers. They receive high marks for their competitive rates, smooth closing process, and knowledgeable loan officers who understand rural property financing challenges common in the Allegany area.