Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Amityville

CrossCountry Mortgage's Bohemia office serves the Amityville area with exceptional customer service and comprehensive mortgage solutions. With over 15 years of experience, Michael D'Ambrosio and his team specialize in guiding Long Island homeowners through the entire mortgage process. They offer competitive rates across all loan types and are particularly noted for their personalized service and expertise with first-time homebuyer programs. The company maintains a 4.9-star rating based on 125+ reviews, demonstrating consistent customer satisfaction and reliable performance throughout the mortgage process.

NRL Mortgage has been serving Long Island communities including Amityville since 2004, with Joseph Gaudio bringing over 12 years of mortgage expertise. The company is highly regarded for its competitive rates and efficient loan processing. They specialize in both purchase and refinance transactions, with particular strength in conventional and FHA lending. With an impressive 4.8-star rating from nearly 90 reviews, NRL Mortgage is known for their transparent communication and ability to close loans quickly, making them a top choice for Suffolk County homebuyers.

As Long Island's largest credit union, Bethpage Federal Credit Union has been serving Amityville and surrounding communities for over 80 years. Their mortgage department offers exceptionally competitive rates for members and provides personalized service through local loan officers. They excel in first-time homebuyer programs, jumbo loans, and various refinance options. With over 350 reviews maintaining a 4.7-star rating, Bethpage is renowned for their community commitment, member-focused approach, and comprehensive mortgage solutions backed by their strong financial stability and local presence.