Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Appleton

Evans Bank is a highly-rated Western New York institution with over a century of service to the region. They maintain exceptional 4.8-star ratings across multiple platforms for their personalized mortgage services and competitive rates. As a community-focused bank with deep roots in Erie and Niagara counties, they specialize in serving the Appleton area with local underwriting and decision-making. Their mortgage team provides comprehensive guidance through the entire home financing process, offering both purchase and refinance options with exceptional customer service that consistently earns top marks from homebuyers throughout Western NY.

Premium Mortgage Corporation has built an outstanding reputation across Western New York with nearly perfect 4.9-star ratings and hundreds of positive reviews. Founded in 1997, they've become one of the region's most trusted mortgage brokers with extensive experience serving Niagara County and the Appleton area. Their team excels at finding competitive rates and ideal loan products for each borrower's unique situation, with particular expertise in first-time homebuyer programs and government-backed loans. The company's commitment to transparent communication and streamlined processes has earned them repeated recognition as a top mortgage lender in the Buffalo-Niagara region.

Five Star Bank brings over 170 years of banking expertise to the Western New York mortgage market, consistently earning high marks for their reliable service and competitive loan products. With a strong presence throughout the Finger Lakes and Western NY regions, they actively serve the Appleton area with localized underwriting and personalized mortgage solutions. Their experienced loan officers provide comprehensive guidance on conventional, government-backed, and construction loans, backed by the stability of a well-established community bank. Five Star Bank's commitment to long-term customer relationships and community development makes them a trusted choice for Appleton homebuyers seeking both competitive rates and exceptional service.