Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Caledonia

As one of the most trusted financial institutions in the Rochester region, ESL Federal Credit Union has been serving the Caledonia area for over a century. They consistently receive exceptional ratings for their competitive mortgage rates, personalized service, and deep community commitment. Their mortgage specialists provide comprehensive guidance through the entire home buying process, with particular expertise in first-time homebuyer programs and local market knowledge. Members praise their transparent process, low closing costs, and exceptional customer service that makes the mortgage experience smooth and understandable.

As the mortgage division of Western New York's largest real estate company, Nothnagle Home Loans has deep roots in the Caledonia and Greater Rochester area. With over seven decades of experience, they offer unparalleled local market expertise and seamless coordination with their real estate services. Customers consistently rate them highly for their responsive communication, competitive rates, and efficient closing processes. Their team includes specialists in various loan types, particularly noted for their expertise with rural properties common in the Caledonia area and their comprehensive first-time homebuyer assistance programs.

Fairway Independent Mortgage has established itself as one of the top-rated mortgage lenders serving the Caledonia area, with multiple local offices and a strong regional presence. They receive exceptional customer satisfaction ratings for their competitive pricing, wide range of loan products, and highly responsive service. Their local loan officers have extensive knowledge of the Livingston County market and are particularly praised for their ability to close loans quickly and efficiently. The company is renowned for their technology platform that provides real-time updates and their commitment to making the mortgage process transparent and stress-free for borrowers.