Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Cattaraugus

Five Star Bank has been serving Western New York communities for over two decades with a strong focus on personalized mortgage solutions. As a regional bank deeply embedded in the Cattaraugus County area, they offer local underwriting and decision-making with competitive rates. Their mortgage team has extensive experience with rural property financing and USDA loans, which are particularly relevant for Cattaraugus homebuyers. Customers consistently praise their responsive service and streamlined application process.

M&T Bank maintains a strong physical presence throughout Western New York with multiple branches serving Cattaraugus County. With over 30 years of mortgage lending experience in the region, they offer comprehensive loan programs including specialized options for first-time homebuyers and rural development loans. Their local loan officers have deep knowledge of the Cattaraugus real estate market and provide personalized guidance through the entire mortgage process. The bank receives high marks for competitive rates and reliable customer service.

Premium Mortgage has built an exceptional reputation throughout Western New York for their expertise in rural and suburban property financing. While based in the Buffalo metropolitan area, they actively serve clients throughout Cattaraugus County and have particular strength with USDA rural development loans. Their team of experienced loan officers provides personalized service with quick turnaround times. Customer reviews consistently highlight their transparency, competitive rates, and ability to handle complex financing situations effectively.