Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Lancaster

Evans Bank is a premier local financial institution with deep roots in Western New York, including a dedicated Lancaster branch. Their mortgage team receives exceptional ratings for personalized service, local decision-making, and competitive rates. As a community bank with over a century of service, they offer the advantage of local underwriting and relationship-based lending while providing comprehensive mortgage products. Their Lancaster location makes them exceptionally accessible to local residents, and they're known for guiding first-time homebuyers through the entire process with exceptional care.

Premium Mortgage Corporation is a highly-rated regional mortgage lender serving all of Western New York, including Lancaster. With their Williamsville headquarters just minutes from Lancaster, they've built an outstanding reputation for competitive rates, exceptional customer service, and efficient loan processing. They specialize in first-time homebuyer programs and offer extensive educational resources. Their team of local mortgage experts understands the Lancaster market dynamics and provides personalized attention throughout the mortgage process, earning them consistently excellent reviews from Erie County homebuyers.

Five Star Bank maintains a strong physical presence in Lancaster with a dedicated branch location, making them a convenient and trusted local mortgage option. As one of Western New York's most established financial institutions, they offer the stability of a regional bank combined with local market expertise. Their mortgage team receives high marks for transparency, competitive rate offerings, and streamlined application processes. They particularly excel at construction and renovation loans, serving the growing Lancaster community with customized mortgage solutions and local underwriting capabilities.