Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Machias

Evans Bank is a highly-rated regional financial institution serving Western New York with deep roots in the community. While headquartered in Hamburg, they actively serve Machias and surrounding Cattaraugus County areas. They receive exceptional ratings for personalized service, competitive rates, and local decision-making. Their mortgage team specializes in rural and suburban properties, offering USDA loans that are particularly valuable for Machias area homebuyers. With nearly a century of experience, they understand the unique needs of Western New York homeowners.

Premium Mortgage is one of Western New York's highest-rated mortgage lenders with multiple offices throughout the region. They consistently receive top marks for customer service, competitive rates, and efficient processing. Specializing in both purchase and refinance loans, they have extensive experience serving rural communities like Machias. Their local loan officers understand the Cattaraugus County market and offer personalized guidance throughout the mortgage process. With thousands of successful closings across Western NY, they've built a reputation for reliability and excellence.

Five Star Bank is a well-established community bank serving Western and Central New York with a strong presence in rural communities. Based in Warsaw, they have deep experience serving areas like Machias and understand the unique aspects of rural property financing. They offer competitive mortgage products with local underwriting and decision-making. Customers consistently praise their knowledgeable staff, transparent process, and commitment to community banking values. Their long history in the region ensures they understand local market conditions and can provide tailored mortgage solutions.