SSL Secured
Privacy Protected
Licensed & Regulated
MortgageLenderNearMe
Olean, NY

The Best Mortgage Lenders in Olean, NY

Compare verified mortgage lenders serving Olean, New York. Find competitive rates on conventional, FHA, VA, and jumbo loans from experienced professionals.

3
Top Lenders
4.7
Avg Rating
410+
Reviews
10
Loan Types

Available Loan Programs in Olean

Conventional
FHA
VA
USDA
Jumbo
Refinance
Construction
First-time Homebuyer
Investment Property
Renovation

Featured Mortgage Lenders

1

Five Star Bank Mortgage Team

Five Star Bank

★★★★☆
4.6/5

Five Star Bank stands out as Olean's premier local mortgage lender with deep community roots spanning over 170 years. As a regional bank headquartered in Western New York, they offer personalized service and local underwriting decisions that national lenders can't match. Their mortgage team has extensive experience with rural property financing and USDA loans, which is particularly valuable in the Olean area. Customers consistently praise their responsive communication, competitive rates, and ability to close loans efficiently. Their physical presence in Olean ensures face-to-face service throughout the mortgage process.

Experience:15 years
Reviews:89 customer reviews
1501 W State St, Olean, NY 14760

Loan Types:

ConventionalFHAVAUSDAJumboRefinanceConstructionFirst-time Homebuyer
Visit Website
2

Prestige Financial Services

Prestige Financial Services, LLC

★★★★☆
4.8/5

Prestige Financial Services is a highly-rated mortgage broker serving Western New York, including Olean, with exceptional customer satisfaction ratings. As a mortgage brokerage, they have access to multiple lenders and can shop for the best rates and terms on behalf of Olean homebuyers. Their team specializes in navigating complex financing scenarios and has particular expertise with rural properties common in the Southern Tier region. Reviewers consistently highlight their transparency, attention to detail, and ability to secure favorable terms that save borrowers money over the life of their loan.

Experience:22 years
Reviews:127 customer reviews
5959 Big Tree Rd, Orchard Park, NY 14127

Loan Types:

ConventionalFHAVAUSDAFirst-time HomebuyerRefinanceInvestment Property
Visit Website
3

Guild Mortgage - Buffalo

Guild Mortgage Company

★★★★☆
4.7/5

Guild Mortgage brings national lending power with strong local expertise through their Western New York office. With over 60 years in business, they offer exceptional stability and a wide range of mortgage products specifically tailored to New York's unique lending requirements. Their Olean-area clients benefit from dedicated local loan officers who understand the Southern Tier housing market, combined with the resources of a top-10 purchase lender nationally. Guild consistently receives praise for their educational approach, making complex mortgage concepts understandable for first-time and experienced buyers alike.

Experience:18 years
Reviews:194 customer reviews
5500 Main St, Williamsville, NY 14221

Loan Types:

ConventionalFHAVAUSDAJumboRenovationRefinanceFirst-time Homebuyer
Visit Website

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about mortgage lending in Olean, NY

What are the current average mortgage rates in Olean, NY, and how do they compare to national averages?

Mortgage rates in Olean typically align closely with national averages, as they are driven by broader economic factors. However, local lenders may offer competitive rates, and it's common to see slightly lower rates in Olean due to the lower cost of living and property values compared to major metro areas. As of recent trends, rates for a 30-year fixed mortgage in Olean often range within 0.125% to 0.25% of the national average, making it advantageous to shop locally.

Are there any first-time homebuyer programs specifically available for Olean, NY, residents?

Yes, Olean homebuyers can access New York State's "SONYMA" (State of New York Mortgage Agency) programs, which offer low down payments, competitive rates, and down payment assistance. Additionally, the City of Olean may occasionally partner with local organizations like the Olean Area Federal Credit Union to provide grants or favorable loan terms for first-time buyers purchasing within city limits, especially for homes in designated revitalization areas.

How does the appraisal process work in Olean given its mix of historic and newer homes?

Appraisals in Olean require appraisers familiar with the local market, which includes a range of historic early-20th century homes in neighborhoods like the North Union Street Historic District and newer constructions on the city's outskirts. Lenders will ensure the appraiser uses comparable sales ("comps") from within Olean or nearby towns like Portville or Allegany, as values can vary significantly based on a home's age, condition, and proximity to amenities like St. Bonaventure University or the downtown area.

What local factors in Olean should I consider when choosing between a fixed-rate and adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM)?

Given Olean's stable but slower-paced real estate market, fixed-rate mortgages are often recommended for long-term residents planning to stay in their homes for many years. However, an ARM might be considered if you plan to sell within 5–7 years, as property values in Olean tend to appreciate gradually. It's also wise to factor in local economic drivers like healthcare (Olean General Hospital) and education, which provide job stability but may not lead to rapid income growth that would favor riskier ARMs.

Are there any special mortgage considerations for buying a multi-family home or investment property in Olean?

Yes, Olean's affordable housing market makes multi-family properties attractive, but lenders may require a larger down payment (often 15–25%) and have stricter credit requirements for investment loans. Additionally, due to Olean's older housing stock, lenders might require thorough inspections for rental properties, particularly for systems like plumbing and heating. It's also important to research local rental demand, which can be influenced by students from St. Bonaventure University and employees at nearby manufacturing or healthcare facilities.

Mortgage Insights

Finding Your Key to Olean: Why a Local Mortgage Broker is Your Best Ally

If you're dreaming of owning a home in Olean, you're likely picturing a charming porch on the North Union Street Historic District, a spacious yard in the West Side neighborhoods, or a cozy retreat near the Allegheny River. Turning that dream into reality starts with financing, and in a unique market like ours, partnering with a local mortgage broker can make all the difference. Unlike a single bank with a limited set of products, a broker acts as your personal guide through the entire lending landscape, and their local expertise is invaluable here in Cattaraugus County.

Olean's housing market presents a fantastic opportunity with its relative affordability compared to larger New York metros, but it also has its own rhythms and nuances. A broker based in Olean understands the appraisal values in different neighborhoods, from the in-demand areas near St. Bonaventure University to the more rural outskirts. They know which lenders are most familiar with the types of homes common here—think older, character-filled properties that may need specialized loan considerations. This local insight helps prevent surprises during the appraisal and underwriting process, keeping your purchase on track.

On a practical level, starting your search for a broker should involve more than a quick online query. Ask for recommendations from your local real estate agent, who works with these professionals daily. When you interview a potential broker, ask them pointed questions: "How many loans have you closed in the City of Olean in the past year?" and "Can you walk me through specific programs for New York State homebuyers?" Their answers will tell you if they have the boots-on-the-ground experience you need.

This leads us to the crucial regional programs that a skilled broker will help you navigate. New York State offers several advantageous programs, like the SONYMA (State of New York Mortgage Agency) loans, which provide low interest rates, down payment assistance, and special options for first-time homebuyers. A knowledgeable Olean broker will know if you qualify for these and can seamlessly integrate them with other local or federal programs. They can also advise on the specific property tax dynamics and closing cost norms in our area.

Your actionable first step is simple: connect with a local mortgage broker before you seriously start house hunting. Get pre-approved through them, not just pre-qualified. This pre-approval, backed by a broker who has shopped your financial profile to multiple lenders, makes you a powerful and serious buyer in the eyes of Olean sellers. It also gives you a clear, realistic budget for homes in the Westgate Plaza area or the East Side. In a competitive situation, this local broker-backed pre-approval can be the edge that helps you secure your perfect Olean home. By choosing a professional who knows our streets as well as they know mortgage rates, you're not just getting a loan—you're gaining a partner invested in your success right here in our community.

Nearby Cities

Explore mortgage lenders in cities near Olean, NY

Why Choose a Mortgage Lender in Olean?

Local Market Knowledge

Lenders who understand Olean's housing market can offer better guidance and competitive rates.

Multiple Loan Options

Access to conventional, FHA, VA, USDA, and jumbo loans tailored to your financial situation.

Proven Track Record

Work with lenders who have years of experience and hundreds of satisfied customers in New York.

Ready to Find Your Perfect Mortgage Lender?

Connect with top-rated mortgage professionals in Olean and get competitive rates on your home loan.