Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Sheridan

Evans Bank has been serving Western New York communities for over a century with a strong focus on personalized mortgage solutions. As a community bank with deep roots in the region, they offer local underwriting and decision-making, which provides faster closings and more flexible terms than many national lenders. Their mortgage team specializes in first-time homebuyer programs and offers competitive rates with exceptional customer service. They have multiple branches throughout Western New York and are highly regarded for their commitment to the local community.

Five Star Bank has been serving Upstate New York communities for over 170 years, providing comprehensive mortgage services with a local touch. Their mortgage specialists offer personalized guidance through the entire home financing process, from application to closing. They are particularly strong in rural and suburban markets like Sheridan, with expertise in USDA loans and other programs beneficial to Chautauqua County residents. The bank consistently receives high marks for their responsive service and competitive rate offerings.

WNY Mortgage Services, operating as Premium Mortgage Corporation, is one of Western New York's highest-rated mortgage brokers with extensive experience serving the entire region including Sheridan. They work with multiple lenders to find the best rates and terms for each borrower's unique situation. Their team of experienced loan officers provides exceptional personalized service and has deep knowledge of the local real estate market. They are particularly praised for their efficient processing, transparent communication, and ability to handle complex financing scenarios.