Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Wellsville

Community Bank has been serving Wellsville and surrounding communities for over 150 years, making them the most established local mortgage lender in the area. They maintain a 4.8-star rating across multiple review platforms with particular praise for their personalized service and local decision-making. As a community-focused bank with deep roots in Allegany County, they offer competitive rates and have mortgage specialists who understand the local real estate market. Their physical presence in Wellsville ensures face-to-face service and quick processing times.

Five Star Bank maintains a strong physical presence in Wellsville with dedicated mortgage professionals serving Allegany County. With over 130 years of operation, they've built a reputation for reliable service and competitive mortgage products. Customers consistently rate them highly for their responsive communication and expertise with rural housing loans, including USDA options that are particularly relevant for the Wellsville area. Their local branch ensures personalized attention throughout the mortgage process.

While based in the Finger Lakes region, Tompkins Community Bank actively serves the Wellsville market and has earned excellent reviews for their mortgage services. With over 150 years in banking, they bring substantial experience to mortgage lending, particularly noted for their competitive rates and efficient processing. Customers highlight their knowledgeable loan officers and smooth closing processes. Their strong regional presence throughout Western New York makes them a reliable choice for Wellsville homebuyers seeking professional mortgage services with competitive terms.