Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Maynard

First Federal Bank of the Midwest is a highly-rated community bank with deep roots in Eastern Ohio, serving Maynard and surrounding communities for over 130 years. They receive exceptional reviews for personalized service and local decision-making. As a community bank, they offer competitive rates with the advantage of local underwriters who understand the rural Ohio market. Their mortgage specialists provide comprehensive guidance through the entire home buying process, making them particularly strong for first-time homebuyers in the region.

Belmont Savings Bank has been serving the tri-county area including Maynard for over a century, with consistently high customer satisfaction ratings for mortgage lending. They specialize in rural and small-town home financing with particular expertise in USDA loans that benefit Maynard area residents. Their local loan officers provide face-to-face service and understand the unique property values in Jefferson County. Customers praise their responsive communication and ability to close loans efficiently while offering competitive rates.

CrossCountry Mortgage's St. Clairsville office serves the Maynard area with outstanding ratings for mortgage services. They combine national lending power with local expertise, offering a comprehensive range of loan products. Their team receives consistent praise for transparent communication, competitive rates, and handling complex financing situations effectively. As a direct lender with in-house underwriting, they can often provide faster closings while maintaining personalized service for Eastern Ohio homebuyers.