Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in New Bremen

Minster Bank stands as one of the most highly-rated community banks serving the New Bremen area with deep roots in Auglaize and Shelby Counties. While headquartered in nearby Minster (just 6 miles from New Bremen), they have built an exceptional reputation for personalized mortgage services with local underwriting and decision-making. Their mortgage team receives consistent praise for competitive rates, transparent communication, and guiding borrowers through the entire process. As a community-focused institution with over a century of service, they offer the stability of a long-established bank with the personal touch of a local lender, making them a top choice for New Bremen residents seeking conventional, government, or construction loans.

Union Home Mortgage maintains a strong regional presence throughout Western Ohio with multiple locations serving the New Bremen market. With corporate roots in nearby Strongsville, Ohio, they've built a reputation for exceptional customer service and competitive rate offerings. Their local loan officers have extensive knowledge of the Auglaize County housing market and receive consistently high marks for responsiveness and expertise in navigating complex loan scenarios. As a direct lender with in-house underwriting, they can often provide faster closings than many competitors. Their comprehensive loan portfolio and digital mortgage experience make them a preferred choice for both purchase and refinance transactions in the New Bremen area.

Fifth Third Bank maintains a significant presence throughout Western Ohio with multiple branches serving the New Bremen region. As one of the largest regional banks in the Midwest, they combine the resources of a major financial institution with local market expertise. Their mortgage division receives strong ratings for competitive conventional and government loan programs, particularly their construction-to-permanent financing options. With physical locations in nearby Troy, Sidney, and other surrounding communities, they offer convenient in-person service while maintaining robust digital mortgage capabilities. Their long history and financial stability provide borrowers with confidence, while their local loan officers have extensive knowledge of the unique aspects of the Auglaize and Shelby County housing markets.