Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Quarryville

Fulton Mortgage Company stands out as one of the top regional mortgage lenders serving Quarryville, with deep roots in Lancaster County dating back over 140 years. They maintain exceptional 4.8-star ratings across multiple review platforms, reflecting their commitment to personalized service and local market expertise. As a division of Fulton Bank, they offer the stability of an established financial institution with the flexibility of a dedicated mortgage team. Their loan officers have extensive knowledge of Lancaster County's unique real estate market, including rural properties common in the Quarryville area. Customers consistently praise their responsive communication, competitive rates, and smooth closing processes.

Members 1st Federal Credit Union has built an outstanding reputation across South Central Pennsylvania, including strong service in Lancaster County and Quarryville. With over 70 years of operation and consistently high customer satisfaction ratings, they offer competitive mortgage products with member-focused service. Their 4.7-star rating reflects hundreds of positive reviews citing low rates, minimal fees, and exceptional guidance through the mortgage process. As a credit union, they prioritize member benefits over profits, resulting in more favorable terms and personalized attention. Their digital mortgage application process receives particular praise for convenience and efficiency while maintaining human support throughout.

Hamilton Mortgage has established itself as a premier mortgage broker serving Lancaster County and Quarryville with an exceptional 4.9-star rating based on numerous verified customer reviews. As an independent mortgage broker, they offer access to multiple lenders and loan programs, providing clients with competitive rate shopping and flexible solutions. Their team brings extensive local market knowledge, particularly valuable for Quarryville's mix of rural properties and suburban homes. Reviewers consistently highlight their responsiveness, attention to detail, and ability to handle complex financing scenarios. Their expertise in USDA rural development loans makes them particularly well-suited for Quarryville homebuyers seeking properties in more rural areas of Lancaster County.