Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Elkhart Lake

Associated Bank stands out as a top regional lender serving Elkhart Lake with deep Wisconsin roots and comprehensive mortgage services. With over 50 years in banking and strong local presence in nearby Sheboygan, they offer personalized service through experienced mortgage officers like Ryan Schmitz. Their high 4.8 rating reflects exceptional customer satisfaction, competitive rates, and expertise in both primary and vacation home financing—particularly relevant for Elkhart Lake's resort community. They provide full banking integration with local decision-making authority.

North Star Mortgage has built an outstanding reputation throughout Sheboygan County with their exceptional 4.9 rating and personalized approach to mortgage lending. Serving Elkhart Lake residents for nearly 20 years, they specialize in finding the right loan products for each borrower's unique situation. Their local expertise in the Elkhart Lake market, combined with access to multiple lending partners, allows them to offer highly competitive rates and flexible terms. The company is praised for responsive communication and guiding clients smoothly through the entire mortgage process.

Waterstone Mortgage brings over two decades of Wisconsin mortgage expertise with a strong statewide presence that includes serving Elkhart Lake homebuyers. With nearly 400 reviews maintaining a 4.7 rating, they've established themselves as one of Wisconsin's most reliable mortgage lenders. Their comprehensive loan programs and construction lending expertise make them particularly valuable in the Elkhart Lake area, where custom homes and vacation properties are common. They combine the resources of a large lender with personalized service through local loan officers who understand the specific dynamics of the Elkhart Lake real estate market.