Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Lake Mills

Waterstone Mortgage is a highly-rated mortgage lender headquartered in Wisconsin with a strong regional presence serving Lake Mills and surrounding areas. Founded in 2000, it has built a reputation for competitive rates, personalized service, and a wide range of loan options. Customers praise its efficient processing, local expertise, and high customer satisfaction, with many reviews highlighting responsive loan officers and smooth closing experiences. Its long-standing operation in Wisconsin ensures deep understanding of local market conditions.

Guaranteed Rate is a nationally recognized mortgage lender with a strong local office in Milwaukee that actively serves the Lake Mills area. Known for its innovative digital platform and competitive rates, it has consistently high ratings for customer service, transparency, and fast closings. Founded in 2000, it offers a comprehensive suite of loan products and has numerous positive reviews citing knowledgeable staff and hassle-free experiences, making it a top choice for borrowers in Southern Wisconsin.

Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation is a reputable lender with a dedicated Madison office that extends services to Lake Mills, offering personalized mortgage solutions with a focus on community involvement. Established in 1996, it boasts high customer satisfaction scores for its attentive loan officers, competitive rates, and efficient processing. Reviews frequently commend its reliability and local expertise, with many customers noting exceptional guidance through the home buying process, solidifying its status as a trusted regional provider.