Top 3 Mortgage Lenders in Sullivan

Lakeland Credit Union stands out as a top-rated local lender serving Jefferson County and surrounding areas including Sullivan. As a member-owned financial cooperative, they offer personalized mortgage services with highly competitive rates and flexible terms. Their mortgage team provides exceptional one-on-one guidance through the entire home buying process, with particular expertise in first-time homebuyer programs and rural property financing. Known for their responsive customer service and local decision-making authority, they maintain a 4.8-star rating across multiple review platforms with customers consistently praising their transparency and efficiency.

First Citizens State Bank has been serving southeastern Wisconsin communities for over a century, with deep roots in Jefferson and Walworth Counties including Sullivan. Their mortgage department earns exceptional reviews for their local expertise and commitment to community banking values. They offer a comprehensive range of mortgage products with competitive rates and are particularly strong in construction lending and agricultural property financing. With local underwriting and decision-making, they provide faster closings and more flexible terms than many larger institutions, backed by their longstanding reputation for reliability and customer-focused service.

Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation maintains a strong presence throughout southeastern Wisconsin with a dedicated team serving Jefferson County and Sullivan area. As one of the nation's largest mortgage lenders with deep local expertise, they combine the resources of a major lender with personalized local service. They consistently earn top ratings for their competitive rates, extensive loan program options, and exceptional customer service. Their local loan officers have extensive experience with rural property financing and Wisconsin-specific programs, while their efficient processing and underwriting teams ensure smooth, timely closings. Multiple review platforms show hundreds of satisfied customers praising their professionalism and communication throughout the mortgage process.